Fashion

I Bought the Same Shirt in Three Colors. Best Decision I Ever Made.

By Emily Zhao — Former “I need something new for every occasion” shopper. Now buys multiples of things that work.

Last updated: April 2026


I used to think that wearing the same thing often was embarrassing. People would notice. They would think I had no style. They would judge me.

So I bought variety. Different colors. Different cuts. Different patterns. My closet looked like a store. But I still felt like I had nothing to wear.

Then one day, I bought a simple black shirt. Nothing special. Cheap, actually. I wore it once. Liked it. Wore it again a few days later.

No one said anything. No one looked at me strangely. No one cared.

A week later, I bought two more of the same shirt. Different colors this time. Same fit. Same fabric.

That was three years ago. I still wear those shirts. And I have never felt more put together.


What I Learned About Repetition

The idea that you need a different outfit every day is a marketing fantasy. No one expects you to look different every time they see you.

Think about people you see regularly. Your coworkers. Your friends. Can you remember what they wore yesterday? Last Tuesday? Probably not.

We think people are paying attention to our clothes. They are not. They are paying attention to themselves.

Once I accepted that, I stopped worrying about repeating outfits. I started buying multiples of things that worked.

Old HabitNew Habit
Buy one of everythingBuy multiples of what fits
Wear it once, forget itWear it often
Closet full of varietyCloset full of things I actually wear
“Nothing to wear”“Which color today?”

What I Buy Multiples Of

I do not buy multiples of everything. Just things that meet three criteria.

1. It fits well. Not almost fits. Not “I can get it tailored someday.” Fits right now.

2. It is comfortable. If I would not wear it on a lazy Sunday, I do not buy it in any color.

3. It goes with most of my other clothes. If it only works with one specific pair of pants, it is not a good candidate for multiples.

Right now, I own the same shirt in four colors. The same sweater in two colors. The same jeans in two washes. The same sneakers in two colors.

That sounds boring. It is not. Because I mix them differently each time.


What I Stopped Buying

I stopped buying statement pieces. The bright jacket. The patterned pants. The “interesting” shirt that I wore once and then avoided because I did not know how to style it.

I stopped buying things just because they were on sale. A cheap shirt I do not wear is more expensive than a pricier shirt I wear weekly.

I stopped buying for my fantasy self. The version of me who goes to fancy parties. Who wears heels. Who has a “going out” top. That person does not exist. I was buying clothes for her. She never wore them.


What People Actually Notice

I asked my friends this question. “What do you remember about what I wear?”

Their answers: not much.

One friend remembered that I wear a lot of black. Another remembered that I wear glasses. No one remembered specific shirts. No one remembered if I repeated outfits.

The only person who noticed was me.

That was freeing. If no one else is paying attention, I can wear whatever I want. Even the same thing three days in a row.


What I Am Not Saying

I am not saying everyone should buy multiples of the same shirt. Some people love variety. Some people express themselves through clothes. That is great.

I am not saying you should never buy anything interesting or unique. If a statement piece brings you joy, buy it.

I am not saying this approach is stylish. It is not stylish. It is just simple. And simple works for me.

I am just saying: if you are tired of staring at a full closet and feeling like you have nothing to wear, try buying multiples of something that works. You might be surprised.


How to Start (If You Want To)

Pick one item you already own and love. Something you reach for often.

Ask yourself: would I wear this in a different color? If yes, buy one more. Just one. Try it for a month.

If you like having two, buy a third. If you do not like it, stop. No harm done.

You do not need to overhaul your whole closet. Just pay attention to what you actually wear. Then buy more of that.